Adobe Commerce (Magento) vs Shopify: Which eCommerce Platform Should You Choose?

Choosing an eCommerce platform affects far more than the online shopping experience. It determines how quickly your business can evolve, integrate new technologies, launch new features, meet customer expectations, and control long-term costs.

Adobe Commerce (formerly Magento) and Shopify are two of the leading eCommerce platforms on the market. Both support businesses generating millions and even billions of dollars in revenue.

Despite common misconceptions, neither platform is universally better than the other. The right choice depends primarily on your business requirements, the complexity of your operations, and your growth objectives.

In this article, we objectively compare Adobe Commerce and Shopify across their key capabilities to help you determine which eCommerce platform is the best fit for your organization.

Adobe Commerce vs Shopify: Key Features and Differences

Flexibility and customization

Adobe Commerce has long stood out for its extensive flexibility.

Access to the source code makes it possible to customize virtually every aspect of the platform. For some industrial and manufacturing businesses with highly specific processes, this level of control remains a significant advantage.

Shopify takes a different approach. The platform prioritizes standardized best practices while offering an extensive ecosystem of extensions, APIs, and native capabilities that address the needs of most modern businesses.

With the introduction of Shopify Functions, composable APIs, and native B2B capabilities in Shopify Plus, the gap between the two platforms has narrowed considerably.

Adobe Commerce may be a better fit if:

• your business model requires extensive customization;
• your competitive advantage depends on highly customized functionality.

Shopify may be a better fit if:

• your processes align with digital commerce best practices;
• you prioritize agility over systematic customization.

Technical debt management

Technical debt is probably one of the most underestimated factors when choosing an eCommerce platform.

Adobe Commerce provides extensive development flexibility, but that freedom also comes with greater technical responsibility.

Every custom development can gradually increase platform complexity. Over time, this can lead to longer and more expensive upgrades, dependencies between modules, extension compatibility issues, and greater maintenance requirements. Increasing complexity can also create additional security considerations and make it harder for the organization to evolve its platform. Over the years, some businesses accumulate significant technical debt that slows down future initiatives.

Shopify, by contrast, operates on a SaaS architecture. Platform updates are managed by Shopify without requiring major version migration projects. This allows technical teams to spend more time on value-generating initiatives rather than maintaining the underlying infrastructure.

Discover the key digital investments B2B manufacturers and distributors should prioritize in 2027, according to Samuel Bilodeau, Finance Director at Novatize.

Total cost of ownership (TCO)

The cost of an eCommerce platform extends beyond licensing fees. Hosting, security, updates, development, and ongoing maintenance must also be considered. With Magento Open Source, the platform’s extensive flexibility generally comes with higher development and maintenance costs. Adobe Commerce adds licensing costs to these technology expenses.

Shopify instead operates on a SaaS model that includes infrastructure, hosting, security, and platform updates. Costs include recurring subscription fees and, depending on the configuration, transaction and app fees. These different models have a direct impact on budgeting: Adobe Commerce provides greater control, while Shopify tends to make a larger portion of technology costs predictable.

Speed of innovation

Artificial intelligence, conversational commerce, new payment methods, omnichannel experiences, and agentic commerce are evolving rapidly. The ability to adopt these innovations quickly is becoming an increasingly important competitive advantage.

Shopify continuously releases new capabilities that become available across its merchant ecosystem.

Adobe Commerce can also support these innovations, but implementing them may require additional development, integration, and validation depending on the organization’s existing architecture.

Performance and scalability

Both platforms can support significant traffic and transaction volumes. Global businesses rely on both Adobe Commerce and Shopify Plus to manage complex product catalogs and high-demand periods such as Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

The key difference lies in the effort required to maintain that performance. With Adobe Commerce, infrastructure, hosting, caching, and performance optimization are important technical responsibilities. With Shopify, much of the underlying infrastructure and platform performance is managed as part of the SaaS offering.

B2B capabilities

Both platforms now offer advanced B2B commerce capabilities.

Adobe Commerce has long provided features such as:

• custom catalogs;
• customer-specific pricing;
• quotes;
• company accounts;
• approval workflows.

Shopify Plus has invested significantly in B2B commerce capabilities in recent years.

Its native features include:

• company-specific catalogs;
• price lists;
• company accounts;
• B2B payment terms;
• quick ordering;
• ERP integrations;
• approval workflows through specialized apps or extensions.

For businesses whose requirements extend beyond the native capabilities of Shopify Plus, Novatize developed SPINE, a B2B accelerator built specifically for Shopify Plus. Rather than starting from scratch with custom development, SPINE accelerates the implementation of advanced B2B functionality while preserving the benefits of a modern and scalable architecture.

SPINE: Novatize’s B2B Accelerator for Shopify Plus

SPINE is designed around the realities of manufacturers and distributors, providing ready-to-use capabilities such as:

• advanced company account, role, and permission management;
• order approval processes;
• Quick Order capabilities;
• shopping lists and recurring orders;
• negotiated pricing and commercial terms synchronized with the ERP;
• real-time inventory availability and lead times;
• complex shipping rules;
• license management when required;
• preconfigured integrations with leading ERP platforms and business systems.

This approach enables organizations to deploy a robust B2B commerce platform faster while limiting custom development that could contribute to technical debt over time.

Ultimately, the decision depends less on whether individual features exist and more on how those capabilities integrate with your technology ecosystem, business processes, and long-term growth strategy.

When Is Adobe Commerce the Better Choice?

Adobe Commerce remains an excellent eCommerce platform when:

• business processes require extensive customization;
• the organization has an experienced development team;
• sufficient resources are available to maintain a complex architecture;
• customization itself provides a strategic advantage.

For some large and global organizations, this level of flexibility and control remains essential.

When Does a Magento to Shopify Migration Become Strategic?

Not every eCommerce replatforming project is driven by missing functionality. In many cases, the decision comes down to whether the existing platform can continue evolving efficiently with the organization.

A Magento to Shopify migration often becomes worth considering when several of the following challenges emerge:

• new features require months of development;
• platform upgrades become increasingly expensive or are repeatedly postponed;
• custom extensions make every change more complex;
• the platform slows down marketing and eCommerce teams;
• maintenance costs are growing faster than the value being created;
• technology complexity is preventing innovation.

At this stage, the challenge is no longer Adobe Commerce itself. It is the technical debt that has accumulated around the existing implementation.

Migrating from Magento or Adobe Commerce to Shopify can provide an opportunity to move toward a modern, standardized, and continuously maintained architecture that can support future growth without recreating the same level of complexity.

The objective is not simply to change eCommerce platforms. It is to restore organizational agility so teams can invest more of their resources in customer experience, innovation, strategic integrations, and growth rather than infrastructure maintenance.

Adobe Commerce or Shopify: Key Questions to Ask

Before choosing an eCommerce platform, ask:

• Does our current platform accelerate or slow down our initiatives?
• How much of our technology budget goes toward maintenance rather than innovation?
• Can our marketing and eCommerce teams launch new experiences quickly?
• Can our architecture support the next evolution of digital commerce, including AI and agentic commerce?
• Is our platform creating more value, or more complexity?

The answers to these questions are often more revealing than a feature-by-feature comparison.

Adobe Commerce and Shopify are both powerful eCommerce platforms designed for different business realities. Adobe Commerce remains a leading solution for organizations that require extensive customization and have the technical resources to maintain that flexibility.

Shopify, meanwhile, is particularly well suited to organizations looking to accelerate growth, reduce technical debt, and benefit from a SaaS platform that continuously evolves with the market.

The decision should therefore never be based solely on a feature checklist. It should align with your business strategy, ability to innovate, technology ecosystem, and long-term vision.

Interested in discussing this with an eCommerce expert?

Our specialists are here to help you identify the best growth opportunities for your online store.

Pierre-Olivier Brassard

Vice President - Products and Technology, Partner

contact@novatize.com+1 844 932-6682

Book an appointment